To Shape a Dragon's Breath: A Promising Start With Room to Grow

Moniquill Blackgoose's "To Shape a Dragon's Breath" has all the ingredients for a captivating young adult fantasy. It presents a unique twist on the dragonrider trope, set against a backdrop of colonialism and cultural clashes. Anequs, a young Indigenous woman, discovers a dragon egg and embarks on a journey to train it, defying societal expectations and exploring the power of dragons and tradition.

The world-building is the novel's strongest aspect. Blackgoose throws us into a world where dragons are a fading memory and the dominant culture clashes with Anequs' heritage. The tension between the two is palpable, adding a layer of depth to the story. Furthermore, the dragon-training aspect is refreshingly unique. Instead of fire-breathing beasts, the dragons in this world manipulate the very essence of "breath" itself, creating intriguing possibilities.

However, the narrative pacing holds the story back at times. The initial sections feel rushed, cramming in world-building details and character introductions at a breakneck speed. Some plot points feel predictable, and the emotional connection to Anequs' struggles could be stronger. The ending, while setting the stage for a sequel, doesn't quite deliver the satisfying conclusion one might hope for.

"To Shape a Dragon's Breath" is a promising debut with a strong foundation. It tackles interesting themes and offers a refreshing take on dragon lore. However, some uneven pacing and a lack of emotional depth prevent it from reaching its full potential. If you're looking for a unique YA fantasy with a focus on cultural identity and a hint of rebellion, this might be worth checking out, especially if you're patient with world-building exposition. However, for those seeking a fast-paced, emotionally gripping story, this one might feel a little slow on the uptake.